Methodology
How the searches, pages, sites and brands on these pages are labelled, with examples and limits.
How labels are made
Every query, page and site gets a label, and the charts count the labels. The prompts and the three surfaces are described on the overview.
- Rules go first. They read the words of a query, the URL and title of a page, and a fixed list of well-known sites. The rules for each label are in the tables below.
- Claude labels what the rules leave open. Claude is an AI model from Anthropic, and it gets the same definitions: queries where several kinds fit or none does, sites that are not on the list, and cited pages the rules could not type.
- In the November 2026 wave the rules decided about six in ten queries, one site in six and 95% of pages. The listed sites are few, but they hold about half of all the pages recorded.
- What Claude sees: the query with its prompt and category; a site's domain with up to three of its page URLs and titles; a cited page's URL, title and site type. Answers from the ChatGPT app are never sent.
- One version per wave. This is classifier c2. A label is stored, so the same query, page or site keeps its label in later waves.
- Open to checking. Each prompt's answer page lists every query and every URL with the label it got.
Query kinds
A kind says what the query asks for, not what came back.
If exactly one kind's words are in the query, that is its kind. If several fit or none does, Claude picks the main kind and, where it applies, a second one. Answer pages show both; the charts count the main kind.
A query names a brand when it contains a brand or product name: one already known from the answers, or one Claude found in the query. Publications, forums and regulators (NerdWallet, Reddit, the EPA) are sources, not brands. A store or marketplace (Walmart, CarMax, Etsy) is a brand when an answer to the same prompt offers it as an option.
Examples are queries from the November 2026 wave.
| Kind | What the rules look for | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Topic searchAn open search about the topic, with no "best" and no brand. | No brand and none of the words below. |
|
| Open list searchA "best …", "top …" or "cheapest …" search with no brand in it, open to whatever comes back. | “best”, “top”, “cheapest”, “alternatives”, “options”, or “for …” with an audience or use. |
|
| List search with its own picksA "best …" search that already names the brands ChatGPT has in mind, like "most fuel efficient SUVs Kia Niro Corolla Cross". It checks its own picks against the lists rather than looking for options. | A list search that also names at least one brand or product. |
|
| Brand checkA search about one named brand or product, to confirm it exists and fits. | A brand or product name, with none of the fact, comparison or review words. |
|
| Fact lookupA search for one detail of a named product: price, fee, rate, spec, availability. | A brand or product name plus “price”, “fee”, “APR”, “rate”, “limit”, “plan”, “specs”, “warranty” or “how much”. |
|
| ComparisonA search that puts two or more options side by side ("X vs Y"). | “vs”, “versus”, “compare”, “difference”, or two named brands joined by “or”. |
|
| Reviews and forumsA search for what other people say: reviews, Reddit, forums, ratings. | “reviews”, “reddit”, “ratings”, “complaints”, “worth it”, or a site: search on a review or community site. |
|
| NewsA search for something recent: news, launches, changes. | “news”, “latest”, “recall”, “lawsuit”, “announced”, or a month with the current year. |
|
| Rules and official sourcesA search for rules, definitions or official data (regulators, standards, government). | “law”, “regulation”, “requirements”, “standard”, IRS, FDIC, FDA, EPA, or a site: search on a government or reference site. |
|
Page types
A page is typed from its URL and title. The page itself is not opened or read.
The rules are tested in the order of the table and the first match wins. A cited page that ends up as “Other” goes to Claude with its URL, title and site type. Pages that were only in the search results stay “Other”.
Examples are page titles from the November 2026 wave.
| Page type | Rule | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Document or data | The URL ends in .pdf, .doc or .docx. | 2026 Fuel Economy Guidefueleconomy.gov |
| Homepage | The URL has no path, or only /en, /us or /home. | AutoTempest: All the cars. One search.autotempest.com |
| Forum thread | A thread URL (/comments/, /thread, /questions/, /forum, /community/) or a known forum site. | Best mattress for side sleeper with hip and back pain?reddit.com |
| Comparison | “vs”, “versus”, “compare” or “comparison” in the title or URL. | Blue Cash Everyday® vs. Blue Cash Preferred®americanexpress.com |
| List article ("best …") | “best”, “top 10” or “10 best” in the title or URL. | Best All-Weather Floor Mats of 2026, Testedcaranddriver.com |
| News story | A dated URL (/2026/03/) or a page on a known news site. | USPS Holiday Shipping Just Got More Expensive. Here’s How to Savekiplinger.com |
| Review | “review” or “reviews” in the title or URL. | Gemini Exchange Review 2026: Fees, Safety and Featurescoinbureau.com |
| Product page | A URL with /pricing, /plans, /product, /shop or /buy. | Restaurant Pricing | SpotOnspoton.com |
| Help or docs | On a brand site, a URL with /help, /support, /docs, /faq or /learn. | Vanguard Brokerage Account: How It Worksinvestor.vanguard.com |
| Category page | A URL with /category, /collections or /browse, or a search page on a marketplace. | Commercial Ice Machines - Restaurant & Industrial Ice Makerskatom.com |
| Other | None of the above. | Safe vehicles for teensiihs.org |
Site types
A site gets one type as a whole, whatever the page. A list of “best” products on a manufacturer's blog is a list article on a brand site.
About 300 well-known sites are on a fixed list, and every .gov and .mil site is reference. Any other site goes to Claude with its domain and up to three of its pages.
| Site type | What it is | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Brand sites | A company’s own site for the products it sells or the services it provides. | capitalone.com, toyota.com, shopify.com |
| Editorial | Publishers of lists, guides and comparisons. | nerdwallet.com, consumerreports.org, caranddriver.com |
| Reviews | Sites and channels that test or review single products. | rtings.com, sleepfoundation.org, youtube.com |
| Community (UGC) | Content written by users: forums, Q&A, customer reviews. | reddit.com, consumeraffairs.com, bbb.org |
| Marketplaces | Marketplaces, stores that sell many brands, aggregators and comparison engines. | walmart.com, ebay.com, cars.com |
| Reference and government | Encyclopedias, government, regulators, standards and medical bodies. | en.wikipedia.org, epa.gov, aad.org |
| News | Press and trade media. | apnews.com, cnbc.com, wsj.com |
| Other | None of the above, for example file and image hosts. | s3.amazonaws.com |
Brands
A brand is a company, product line or model that an answer names as an option for the reader.
- In the app, ChatGPT tags the brands in its answers. Names it writes without a tag, in tables or on product cards, are matched against the brands already known for the category.
- API answers carry no tags, so Claude lists the brands each one names.
- Not brands: publications cited as sources, government and medical bodies, standards, and ingredients or generic drugs such as minoxidil and retinol.
- One name per product. “The Platinum Card from American Express” and “American Express Platinum” count as one. A trim or size belongs to its product. A company and its product stay apart: Capital One and Capital One Savor are two.
Limits
Labels are judgments made from little text, and some are wrong.
- The labels have not been scored against a hand-labelled sample, so there is no error rate to report yet.
- Page types rest on words in the URL and title. “Best” in a title makes a list article even when the page is a store's category, and “review” also catches scientific review papers.
- “Other” is the largest page type: 38% of the pages in the November 2026 wave, most of them pages that were in the search results and never cited.
- A site has one type, so a store that also publishes guides is still a marketplace, and a publisher that also sells is still editorial.
- The word rules miss wording they do not list. A search for a fund's “expense ratio” reads as a brand check, not a fact lookup.
- On the app the text of some searches is hidden. Kinds can only be given to the queries that were seen or that ChatGPT listed.